|HOME | NEWS | COLUMNISTS | ARVIND LAVAKARE|
June 12, 2001
One irony and one mystery too many
It's an irony that has escaped our mush media and purblind prime minister. The fact is that just a day before India decided to invite Pakistan's chief executive for talks, his commerce minister had flatly rejected our visiting businessmen's demand for granting Most Favoured Nation status. Why, on the very day that our waning PM's pen was waxing eloquent about 'the high road to peace', the general himself had refused to meet a delegation of SAARC Chambers of Commerce and Industry that included an Indian team.
The fact is that the Government of India, having unilaterally accorded MFN status to Pakistan in the mindless manner of Vajpayee's unilateral 'cease-fire' last November, has been asking Islamabad for a reciprocal gesture. The potential trade between the two countries is being projected at $10 billion a year as against the present official trade of $150-200 million.
The fact, again, is that Islamabad's standard response has been that the question of MFN status to India is linked to resolution of all disputes with New Delhi, including the "core issue" of what it erroneously calls Kashmir instead of Jammu & Kashmir.
It is to that small, indigent and fanatical country that cares a tuppence for trade with India and trades in J&K's future at the cost of $10 billion of commerce a year that Vajpayee has now bent his and his nation's knees, fondly hoping to ensconce it in his 'mansion of peace'. That is the irony.
If the reason for this kowtowing is as yet a mystery, there are two other mysteries, and they concern the Kashmiri Pandits, more than half a million of whom have been displaced from the Kashmir valley since 1990, forced to live as refugees in their own country.
The mystery is not why their plight is what it is. That is easily explained: the Muslim majority in the Valley merely indulged in prolonged ethnic cleansing, unrestrained by any government in the state and at the Centre or human rights organisations, national or international, that otherwise meddle to protect even the marauding jihadi.
The mystery is why it has taken so many years for the Government of India to ascertain -- as its emissary K C Pant did the other day -- that the Hindus of J&K want a separate homeland for themselves to the north and east of the Jhelum river with the status of a Union territory and without the fetters of Article 370.
The mystery is why, even as a delegation of Kashmiri Pandits were putting their demand to Pant, the Vajpayee emissary, a United States congressman, Frank Pallone, was putting almost that same demand in his personal letter to Vajpayee himself, pleading that he take up the plight of Kashmiri Pandits during his forthcoming talks with Pervez Musharraf.
The question here is whether the Kashmiri Pandits found a lawmaker in distant New Jersey accessible and receptive, but not their own PM. That is the mystery, if not the tragedy, of how Vajpayee has handled the J&K quicksand all along.
Our 'secular' media has probably expended more print and digital time in the last 12 months in publicising the views of the hypocritical Hurriyat leaders than they have in the last 11 years to highlighting the trauma suffered by the Kashmiri Pandits. Whatever the fellow countrymen know about them has been largely hearsay.
Below, therefore, are but portions strung together from an account rendered by a Kashmiri Pandit, Nancy Kaul by name, at a public seminar held in Chennai in January this year.
The billion-dollar question is whether, with Pallone's letter -- if not with Pant's report -- Prime Minister Vajpayee will do anything at all to save the Kashmiri Pandits from extinction. In any case, the way to lift that community from its present exile to its pristine glory is not through goody-goody talks with General Musharraf, but through acting tough with Dr Farooq Abdullah. But just how a confused 78-year-old man with two artificial knees can at all do that is the final mystery of this week.
|Tell us what you think of this column|
ASTROLOGY | NEWSLINKS | BOOK SHOP | MUSIC SHOP | GIFT SHOP | HOTEL BOOKINGS
AIR/RAIL | WEDDING | ROMANCE | WEATHER | WOMEN | E-CARDS | SEARCH
HOMEPAGES | FREE MESSENGER | FREE EMAIL | CONTESTS | FEEDBACK