Music director and Indian Idol judge Anu Malik chatted with fans last week, discussing the hit reality show among other things. As the final show for Indian Idol 2 approaches (April 22), the contestants are clearly a hot topic of discussion.
For those who missed the chat, here's the second and last part of the transcript:
gavlin asked, IS Indian Idol a rip of American IDOL IS there any truth behind this huge reality hungama
Anu Malik answers, It's the same format which has been bought from Freemantle.
prasanna asked, Hi ... Please select Karunya... as he is Gifted like Kishore Kumar. Farah Khan is biased towards Sandeep due to his good looks I feel. She is not a good judge for Singers...she maybe good for dancers.
Anu Malik answers, I would not like to comment on any of my co judges..
soujanya asked, Sir, how do you feel to be a judge for such popular reality show?
Anu Malik answers, It feels great and its an honour..
shabbir asked, hi your new movie hkdkg is really fantastic
Anu Malik answers, Thank you so much for your love adulation and continued support
raman asked, where do u see urself 5 yrs down the line ????
Anu Malik answers, I see myself composing for Hindi films as well as International stuff
vikky asked, hi ru sure that indian idol is genuine competetion to search a born n gifted singer
Anu Malik answers, Absolutely
zephyr asked, Hi anu ji... ye pyare mohan tune is really rocking
Anu Malik answers, Thank you for the attention it deserves
fanofanu asked, What is the difference between Anu Malik of "Julie Julie, Johny kaa dil tujpe aayaa Julie " and aajkaa Anu Malik of "Tumse Milke dilakaa hai jo haal kyaa kare"
Anu Malik answers, A lot of differences ive updated myself ive grown as a composer and i am in tune with the times and i hope to continue doing better
sanju asked, i like u r song sir sir o sir v love u
Anu Malik answers, I love that song too
preeti asked, Rather than being a stage in which to showcase ones talent, indian idol has become a stage for showcasing the histrionics of all the participants involved. dont u wish more air time was alloted to actual talent and less to the drama behind it ?
Anu Malik answers, I think its a very good reality show where apart from singing you get to know the participants personally and therein lies the beauty
raman asked, i want 2 know which song is ur best composed dong till now ????
Anu Malik answers, yet to come..
Ganesh asked, dont you think that music plays a big part in a song being liked ? so a participant might loose out if the musicians dont deliver.
Anu Malik answers, I think music is al about team work
Sam asked, hi, Anuji, Are you doing any of films with Mr Gordhan tanwani or Mr vashu Bhagnani
Anu Malik answers, Vashu Bhagnani yes.. And Gordhan Tanwani will happen
shabbir asked, WHAT WOULD YOU LIKE TO TELL ABOUT SALMAN SENTENCE WAS IUT RIGHT OR HE IS PAYING 4 HIS CELEBRITY STATUS
Anu Malik answers, DOnt know the merits of the case.. the law will take its own course.. but i felt the sentence is a bit too harsh.
amar asked, don't think u praise too much to karunya on other hand sandeep as a just guy knowing nothing. u judges seem to come in the show with pre planned comments.
Anu Malik answers, We dont pre plan the comments..
nikhilesh asked, Hi, Anu, could u please tell what is the use of producing such C grade singers and being yourself involved in this are not hampering your goodwill you earned by your marevellous tunes?
Anu Malik answers, The singers are not as un-happening as you think they are.. Karunya has been a find and so was Ahbijeet Sawant
Harry asked, Do U Think Your Voice Is Good For Playback Singing
Anu Malik answers, Yes i do for songs which suit my range and expressions
nilesh asked, is knowledge of classical music a must to be a successful music director
Anu Malik answers, Yes absolutely
Vicky asked, Anuji Wats your Age now ?
Anu Malik answers, 43
wasim uk asked, first and foremost i would just like to say that you have always been my fav composer for the past 13years since i heard your album 'Sir' and after that every movie you have done with Mahesh Bhatt
Anu Malik answers, Thank you so much Wasim and i hope to churn out better and better stuff for such sensitive listeners like you
syd asked, Why Indian Music lacks originality? Why some song numbers even if they are hit lack the evergreen taste these days. So you may feel like listening to them again and again? Are people not experimenting much before throwing them to the producers?
Anu Malik answers, ten years down the line the music we are churning out today will be compared to music that comes out later on and then people will say why isnt music like it used to be
Puneet asked, I am also very Good at Singing but due to exces of work not getting the time to practice. I am aging 35 .. may i partcipate in ne competitions to fulfill me dreams
Anu Malik answers, Unfortunately the age limit is 30..
deepak asked, hi anuji...do u also vote for indian idol..if yes then whom u'll b voting between sandeep n karunya
Anu Malik answers, If i could, i would vote for both
anandvasai asked, As very polite, presenting & attractive character, what you make very angry in your life?
Anu Malik answers, I dont get ruffled easily. Because i believe in channelising my energies towards creativity and thats the reason for so many tunes
amar asked, u judjes seem to carry too much of ur emotions in the show.don't be such a one sided one.
Anu Malik answers, We are not one sided
badal asked, hello anuji like Mein Hoon Na, I PRAY GOD HKDKDG MUST BE BIG HIT.
Anu Malik answers, Thank you for your prayers Badal
nasalex asked, anuji i am ur fan. Dont u think rise of Himesh reshammiya is more to do with vaccume left by the absence of cacaphonies like bappi lahiri, as both bappi and himesh's music is soul-less and just chavanni-chaap, as people has forgotton bappi now, will do same with himesh.
Anu Malik answers, Time will tell
Anu Malik says, Thank you everyone.. Unfortunately we dont have more time.. It was great talking to you guys!!! Keep listening and have a great day!
More from rediff