Shailesh Methta, studying on his cramped up desk was burning the mid-night oil as his SAT exam was three days later.
His desk looked like an expensive American bookstore with Kaplan, Princeton Review and Barrons labels spread all over.
On the side of his desk, hidden by all the clutter was an ACT brochure. At the back of his mind, Shailesh was now thinking whether he really needed to take the SAT.
The ACT, America's most widely used undergraduate admissions test, will now be offered in Mumbai. Being in existence for over 47 years now, few Mumbai students are aware of this test. Easier and cheaper than the SAT, students may prefer abandoning the SAT for this test.
ACT web site states: 'Virtually all colleges and universities accept ACT scores. The test measures what students have learned in high school and many students find it more comfortable because there are no trick questions. Colleges only see the scores that the students want them to see. And it's not the kind of college admissions exam that requires expensive test preparation courses.'
"For the longest time, undergraduate students looked only at the SAT for their US college applications. When we realised that the ACT can be used as an alternative to the SAT, we agreed to the act as the ACT testing centre," states Kamal Gupta, Chairman of Lala Lajpat Rai Institute of Management, the ACT testing centre in Mumbai.
ACT versus SAT in Mumbai
All about ACT
It has four sections -- English, Math, Reading and Science Reasoning. The English section has 74 questions on sentence correction, the Math section has 60 math problems on Class XI and Class XII topics, the Reading section has 40 questions on reading comprehension and the Science Reasoning section has 40 questions on logical science reasoning. And don't let the name "Science Reasoning" fool you. This section does not need prior scientific knowledge and can be answered using your logic and common sense. The ACT also has an optional writing section which is offered on some testing dates in India.
Disadvantages
This brings us to the disadvantage of the ACT. Many colleges in the US need the writing test from applicants. And since the SAT II Writing test is not offered anymore, students will have to appear for the SAT exam to get a writing score.
Therefore, if your college needs the writing test, you will have to appear for the ACT as well as the SAT (unless you take the ACT with writing offered once a year). Many feel that this is not necessarily a disadvantage.
SAT + ACT?
"I encourage my students to take both the SAT as well as the ACT. The tests are different and some students may find they are more comfortable with one test over the other. When the students receive their results, they can then decide if they want to retake either test. As long as the schools they are applying to accept either test or admission, I would advise them to retake the one that they felt most comfortable with and received the higher score, " states Katie Freeman, Guidance Counselor of the American Embassy School in New Delhi.
"Again, the students should check with the schools they are interested in applying to and make sure they accept either test for admission. Additionally, they should verify whether the school requires the writing assessment, as the ACT writing option is not currently available to take in India," she adds.
"None of my friends have heard about the ACT. But after I read the syllabus and tried a test, I am confident that this exam is easier than the SAT. I hate writing essays and now I won't have to," states Abhinav, an undergraduate student.
"The ACT is more straightforward because the questions are less tricky. Like the SAT, there is no specific matter to be learnt but unlike the SAT, there is no need to spend time on learning wordlists," says Helen Mathur, an education consultant.
Look over the test papers for the ACT as well as the SAT and decide which exam is easier for you. If the SAT makes you nervous and unhappy, you now have an alterative.
Mumbai Centre for ACT
Lala Lajpat Rai College,
Mahalaxmi
Mumbai-34
Phones: (022) 24980874
More from rediff